Gua sha and dry brushing promise a lot: to drain, detoxify, sculpt, smooth cellulite, and boost collagen. On social media, these practices have become almost therapeutic rituals.
The scientific reality is more modest – and we prefer to tell you frankly. These practices are useful, but not in the ways marketing suggests.
A pleasant gesture doesn't need exaggerated promises to have a place in a routine.
What really happens under the stone
When you use a gua sha or a roller on your face, the measurable effect is circulatory. One study showed that a five-minute massage increases local cutaneous blood flow, and this influx persists for about ten minutes after the practice. This is what gives that rosier complexion and the impression of a "awakened" face. But the effect is transient: the skin then returns to its baseline state.
The myth of drainage and detox
The most common argument – "it drains toxins" – is not physiologically sound. The skin does not accumulate toxins that a manual massage would remove; this job falls to the liver and kidneys. Manual lymphatic drainage, for its part, only has serious evidence in a specific medical context, lymphedema, and even there the data on quality of life remain uncertain. Nothing supports the idea of a "detox" of healthy facial skin through gua sha.
Sculpt, firm, produce collagen?
Anti-aging promises are the most fragile. A randomized controlled trial comparing rollers and gua sha observed measurable effects on contours and tone, but these were modest and did not demonstrate sustained collagen stimulation. No robust data shows that a tool applied superficially can boost deep collagen synthesis. What you gain is mainly due to temporary decongestion and muscle relaxation, not dermal remodeling.
Dry brushing, between exfoliation and illusion
For the body, dry brushing suffers from the same oversimplifications. Its only truly demonstrated benefit is exfoliation: it removes dead skin cells and leaves the skin smoother to the touch. However, the idea that it dislodges cellulite or "activates the lymph" is not supported – the lymphatic system is primarily stimulated by muscle contraction, not by skin brushing. The smoothed appearance after brushing comes from increased blood flow, and it fades within a few hours.
Precautions not to neglect
These practices are not harmless for all skin types. On skin prone to rosacea, couperose, or fragile capillaries, friction and blood flow can accentuate redness and dilation. Also avoid on damaged skin, an eczema flare-up, inflammatory acne, or moles. Light pressure, slow movement, always on clean skin and with a little oil or serum for the face: if the gesture pulls or reddens the skin, it means too much pressure is being applied.
The Paradermia approach
We don't demonize gua sha or dry brushing: they are pleasant rituals, a moment of pause, and provide a real, albeit brief, "healthy glow" effect. Our position as pharmacists is simply to place them at their proper level of evidence. They do not replace sun protection, nor proven active ingredients like retinoids or vitamin C for aging concerns. Consider them as a pleasure and a moment of relaxation, not as an active treatment – and you will never be disappointed.
Frequently asked questions
Does gua sha really de-puff the face?
Partially, and temporarily. Massage increases local circulation for about ten minutes and can alleviate a puffy feeling upon waking. But the effect is transient: it doesn't drain toxins and doesn't permanently alter facial contours.
Does dry brushing reduce cellulite?
No. No solid data shows that dry brushing dislodges fat deposits or acts on cellulite beyond a temporary visual smoothing due to increased blood flow. Its only real and demonstrable effect is the exfoliation of the skin's surface.
Do these practices pose any risks?
For most people, no, provided you go gently. On skin prone to couperose or rosacea, with fragile capillaries, or in cases of eczema, inflammatory acne, or lesions, it's best to abstain: friction can worsen redness and irritation.
Sources
- Miyaji A, Sugimori K, Hayashi N. (2018). Short- and long-term effects of using a facial massage roller on facial skin blood flow and vascular reactivity. Complement Ther Med. doi:10.1016/j.ctim.2018.09.009
- Ahn J, et al. (2025). Comparative effects of facial roller and gua sha massage on facial contour, muscle tone, and skin elasticity: a randomized controlled trial. J Cosmet Dermatol. doi:10.1111/jocd.70236
- Müller M, Klingberg K, Wertli MM, Carreira H. (2018). Manual lymphatic drainage and quality of life in patients with lymphoedema and mixed oedema: a systematic review of randomised controlled trials. Qual Life Res. doi:10.1007/s11136-018-1796-5